Snowball vs. avalanche: how they work
Both methods use the same monthly budget: the minimum on every debt plus an extra amount. Every debt gets its minimum, and all the extra goes to one target debt. When the target is paid off, its minimum payment “rolls” into the next one, so the payment aimed at each debt keeps growing.
- Debt snowball: target the smallest balance first. You clear whole debts sooner, which many people find motivating.
- Debt avalanche: target the highest APR first. With the same budget this costs the same or less interest, because the most expensive balance shrinks first.
Worked example: $23,000 of debt, five budgets
Four debts totaling $23,000: a $6,500 card at 24.99% ($195 minimum), an $11,000 car loan at 6.9% ($340), a $1,500 loan at 9% ($60) and a $4,000 personal loan at 14.5% ($140). The minimums add up to $735 a month. With $300 extra ($1,035 in total), the avalanche pays the card first and costs $3,064.22 in interest; the snowball pays the $1,500 loan first and costs $3,611.45. Both are debt-free in 26 months, and the avalanche saves $547.23. Here is the same set of debts with different amounts of extra:
| Extra a month | Total payment | Debt-free (avalanche / snowball) | Interest, avalanche | Interest, snowball | Avalanche saves | First debt gone (snowball / avalanche) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $0 | $735 | 40 / 40 months | $6,277.57 | $6,289.60 | $12.03 | month 28 / 28 |
| $100 | $835 | 34 / 34 months | $4,562.90 | $5,084.33 | $521.43 | month 10 / 28 |
| $200 | $935 | 29 / 30 months | $3,633.40 | $4,217.17 | $583.77 | month 6 / 21 |
| $300 | $1,035 | 26 / 26 months | $3,064.22 | $3,611.45 | $547.23 | month 5 / 16 |
| $500 | $1,235 | 21 / 21 months | $2,375.65 | $2,824.86 | $449.21 | month 3 / 11 |
Two things stand out. The extra payment matters far more than the method: going from $0 to $300 extra saves $3,213.35 with the avalanche, about six times the gap between the two methods. And with no extra at all the methods barely differ ($12.03), because the only money that follows the plan is each paid-off minimum rolling forward, which doesn’t start until month 28. What the snowball buys is speed to the first win: month 5 instead of month 16 at $300 extra.
When the method makes a big difference
The avalanche’s advantage grows with the size of the high-rate balance and the spread between rates:
- A large card balance. Make the 24.99% card $15,000 (minimum $450) and keep the other three debts and $300 extra ($1,290 a month). The avalanche finishes in 30 months with $6,806.41 of interest; the snowball takes 32 months and $8,527.56. The avalanche saves $1,721.15, because the snowball leaves the biggest, most expensive balance until third.
- Rates close together. Give the same four debts APRs of 12%, 10%, 11% and 11.5% (the original balances and $300 extra). Now the avalanche saves only $25.42 and both finish in 25 months. Here the snowball’s quicker wins cost almost nothing.
So run your own numbers: if the gap is a few dollars, choose whichever order keeps you paying; if it is in the thousands, the avalanche is worth the wait for the first payoff.
Which method should you choose?
If you will stick with either plan, the avalanche is cheaper. The gap is small when your APRs are close or your balances are small, and large when a big balance carries a high rate. If quick wins keep you going, the snowball's extra cost may be worth it. A plan you finish beats a cheaper plan you abandon. Either way, the biggest savings come from the extra payment itself.
Snowball, avalanche or a consolidation loan?
A consolidation loan only helps if it lowers the rate on the debts you move into it. With the same $1,035 a month:
- Consolidating everything ($23,000) into one loan at 11.99% costs $3,138.77 in interest over 26 months, $74.55 more than the avalanche on the original debts, because it moves the 6.9% car loan to a higher rate.
- Consolidating only the high-rate debts (the $6,500 card and the $4,000 personal loan, $10,500, keeping their combined $335 payment) at 11.99% cuts the avalanche’s interest to $2,203.67 and finishes in 25 months, saving $860.55 before fees.
- With a 5% origination fee added to that loan ($11,025 borrowed), the total paid is $25,861.39 against $26,064.22, a saving of only $202.83.
Fees and the rate you actually qualify for decide whether it is worth it; compare offers with the debt consolidation calculator and the APR calculator. Lenders must disclose the APR and finance charge before you sign (Regulation Z).
What this calculator does and doesn’t model
- Does: up to four fixed-rate debts, a fixed total budget every month (all the minimums plus your extra), each paid-off minimum rolling into the next target, and interest charged monthly at APR ÷ 12.
- Falling minimums. Card minimums usually shrink as the balance falls. The plan keeps paying the original minimum, which is the point: paying only what is due would take much longer (see the credit card payoff calculator).
- Promotional and penalty rates. A 0% balance-transfer period, deferred interest or a penalty APR after a late payment change the order that makes sense. Enter the rate that applies for most of the plan, or rerun when it changes.
- New charges, fees and annual fees aren’t included.
- Debts in collection or charged off don’t follow a normal minimum payment; settlement and collection rules are different (see the CFPB on debt collection).
- Prepayment penalties on some personal or car loans. Most consumer loans have none, but check the contract before targeting one.
- More than four debts: combine small debts with similar rates into one line, or run the plan in two passes.
Common mistakes
- Not rolling the freed-up minimum forward. When a debt is paid off, its payment must go to the next target; spending it instead turns the plan back into minimums-only, the slowest row in the table above.
- Still charging on the cards. New purchases on a card you are paying down undo the plan month by month. Use the card for nothing, or only what you pay in full.
- Paying a low-rate loan early “to get rid of it”. Extra money on a 6.9% car loan while a 24.99% card stays at its minimum costs real interest. Even snowball users often put the largest, cheapest loan (car, student loan) last.
- A minimum below the monthly interest. If a card’s minimum doesn’t cover its interest, the balance grows until the plan reaches it. The calculator warns you when this happens; pay at least the interest.
- No emergency cushion. Putting every spare dollar into debt and then charging a car repair restarts the cycle. A small cash buffer first keeps the plan intact.
- Closing every paid-off card. Closing accounts can raise your credit utilization ratio; many people keep an old no-fee card open and unused.
- Missing a due date while focusing on the target. Every other debt still needs its minimum on time; a late payment can bring a fee and, after 60 days, a penalty APR on a card. Autopay the minimums.
Frequently asked questions
Is the debt avalanche always cheaper than the snowball?
With the same monthly budget, paying the highest APR first costs the same or less interest. The two give identical results when the smallest balance also has the highest rate.
How much does the avalanche really save?
It depends on your debts. On $23,000 spread over a 24.99% card, a 6.9% car loan and two smaller loans, with $300 extra a month, the avalanche saves $547.23. Make the card $15,000 and it saves $1,721.15; put all four rates between 10% and 12% and it saves $25.42.
How much extra should I pay each month?
Whatever you can keep up every month. In the example on this page, $100 extra cuts payoff from 40 to 34 months and saves $1,714.67 of interest with the avalanche; $300 extra gets to 26 months and saves $3,213.35. Each added dollar also earns the rate of the debt it pays down.
Can I switch from snowball to avalanche partway through?
Yes. Rerun the calculator with your current balances; the plan only depends on what you owe today. Many people start with the snowball to clear one or two small debts and then switch to the highest rate.
What counts as the minimum payment?
Use the minimum on your latest statement. The calculator keeps each minimum fixed; real card minimums usually shrink as the balance falls, so keeping the same total payment, as this plan does, pays debt off faster than paying only what is due.
Should I include my mortgage?
Usually not. Snowball and avalanche plans are meant for consumer debt such as credit cards, car loans and personal loans. A mortgage at a low rate would come last in the avalanche anyway and its size would dominate the snowball.
Does a debt consolidation loan beat both methods?
Only if the new APR, after fees, is lower than the rates you are paying and you do not run the cards back up. Compare the payment, interest and fees with the debt consolidation calculator.
Sources
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB): Credit cards (minimum payments)
- CFPB: Regulation Z (Truth in Lending: APR and finance charge disclosures)
- CFPB: Debt collection
Last reviewed . How we review and test pages.